
The Fundamental Flaw
“Believe in yourself! Have faith in your abilities! Without a humble but reasonable confidence in your own powers, you cannot be successful or happy.”[i]
Reading this encouragement from a self-help book about the potential of my mind and positive thinking captivated me. It left me feeling nothing but power. It even included Scripture references to this “power” within. So I knew it was legit. There was no denying this was God’s will for my life.
I couldn’t put the book down. I never knew that simply changing the way I thought would literally change the circumstances around me. Happiness, greatness, confidence, likability, assertiveness, wealth, romance, a fresh start, a positive perspective—there was a book or conference for that. But it wasn’t just my perspective that would change. No, my thoughts could change my reality. I was magical. There was definitely nothing suspicious about this. What a serotonin rush!
A rush that eventually crashed into this really inconvenient thing called reality.
It didn’t take long to realize that this “powerful thoughts” thing would require doing the work to be better. Eat better, think better, act better.
Just be better.
And this is how it gets you.
The inspiring quote at the beginning of this section is the first words you’ll read in Norman Vincent Peale’s tremendously popular self-help book, The Power of Positive Thinking. It’s one of the most successful self-help books ever sold in American history. It also happens to be one of the most popular New Thought books ever sold in American history.
Peale was a popular New Thought author and minister. His influence is just one of many New Thought sources that have influenced our culture’s views on positive thinking, self-reliance, following your truth, and, well, everything to do with yourself as the answer to your problems.
The theme is still the same: self. You’re the chosen hero. You’re not the problem. You’re the solution. The downsides to this message are many, including the huge barrier it builds to accepting the gospel. And tragically, those who follow the religion of self-improvement ultimately become a slave to its never-ending, works-based demands.
That’s the result of a fundamental flaw in how New Thought depicts humanity. Nearly every false idea today can be traced back to the belief that humanity is fundamentally good.[ii] This creates the illusion of rediscovering something deep within and awakening our divine potential. Some people can’t understand why they’d need a savior. I’m my own savior. I am enough!
New Thought began with healing, but it grew to promote personal prosperity and correct the “lie” that humans were inherently sinful. Humanity didn’t need to be told they were sinners. They needed to know about their goodness and inner divinity, the Christ within, and that they are already whole. They just need to realize it. Supposedly, the lies of the religious fundamentalists had been holding people back. This was nothing but fear-filled religious propaganda, keeping humans from reaching their true potential.
[i] Norman Vincent Peale, The Power of Positive Thinking (New York, Simon and Schuster: 2015), pg 1.
[ii] Natasha Crain, “Nearly every false idea today can be traced back to the belief that man is fundamentally good,” Facebook, April 25, 2023. https://tinyurl.com/ytc4e9wr.
Happy Lies Copyright © 2025 by Melissa Dougherty
Published in Grand Rapids, Michigan, by Zondervan. Zondervan is a registered trademark of The Zondervan Corporation, L.L.C., a wholly owned subsidiary of HarperCollins Christian Publishing, Inc.
Listen or Watch our interview with Melissa Dougherty on SBE here!
The post Loving Ourselves to Death: Self-Help and New Thought appeared first on Key Life.

